CDC Stands for "Can't Decide Completely"
CDC Stands for "Can't Decide Completely"
The Circus For Disease Confusion is a mess
I've never seen so much confusion in my life. This whole pandemic and the reactions to it are a complete and utter disaster - on many levels. The madness started with a haphazard response federally but has taken hold on the state level. Now it seems to be circling back to the feds again. The government has failed us.
We should rename the Centers For Disease Control, the Circus For Disease Confusion, or Can't Decide Completely.
The C.D.C. is changing their guidance, again. They seem to be making things up as they go along. Haven't they seen pandemics before?
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention clarified its guidance to prevent the coronavirus from spreading. It appears they're hoping to clear up the mess they made and the paranoia they've spread over the past three months. There has been widespread confusion over whether a person can contract COVID-19 by touching surfaces that have the coronavirus on them. They admitted this week that it appears the coronavirus is not easily transmissible on surfaces. I guess we can get rid of the blue surgery gloves and stop stocking up on Clorox wipes. We can also immediately cease emptying cans of Lysol on Amazon.com packages and all grocery bags.
This seems in complete opposition to the dire warnings issued on March 17 when the National Institutes of Health teamed up with Mensa members from the C.D.C., UCLA, and Princeton. They said (SARS-CoV-2) was detectable in aerosols for up to three hours, up to four hours on copper, up to 24 hours on cardboard, and up to two to three days on plastic and stainless steel.
If you read their previous guidance and reports, you might have concluded that nothing was safe. You couldn't go anywhere because the coronavirus was all around you. Cities and towns across America closed playgrounds and parks to protect poor little children who could be super-spreaders if they wound up touching contaminated monkey bars and swings. Online stores sold out of disinfecting shoe trays that promised to kill the virus on the soles of our flip-flops. The C.D.C. said people should continue to clean and disinfect dirty surfaces that could be harboring the virus.
I feel our state government thinks we're all in pre-school now. It's as absurd as the public service announcements telling us to wash our hands. Shouldn't we clean dirty surfaces anyway?
While it makes sense to be careful, was anyone thinking this through? This agency seems to have forgotten the lessons of the many past pandemics. The "experts" tell us things that often don't make much sense. There are patterns and cycles. There are mountains of historical data. Every "novel" virus tends to wind up like most others we've seen. Miraculously, humanity manages to survive every pandemic.
Cooking The Books
The C.D.C. is not only flip-flopping on their guidance; they are muddying the picture of the entire pandemic. The C.D.C. is conflating the results of two different types of coronavirus tests. This, in turn, distorts several essential metrics. Now that serology tests, which look for antibodies in the blood of people who have recovered, are more widespread, C.D.C. officials said Friday they would work to separate serology tests results from diagnostic tests, which detect active infection.
One of the agency's data tracker websites has combined test results that diagnose current coronavirus infections with test results that measure whether someone has ever had the virus. The agency confirmed to The Atlantic on Wednesday that it is mixing the results of viral and antibody tests, even though the two tests reveal different information and are used for various reasons.
NPR's WLRN station in Miami first reported it. Combining the tests inhibits the agency's ability to discern the country's actual testing capacity.
"You've got to be kidding me," Ashish Jha, director of the Harvard Global Health Institute, told The Atlantic. "How could the C.D.C. make that mistake? This is a mess."
A spokeswoman for the C.D.C., Kristen Nordlund, said viral testing was much more common than antibody testing in the pandemic's early days. Some states combined the virus tests with the few antibody results they had.
In the Atlantic:
Several states—including Pennsylvania, the site of one of the country's most significant outbreaks, and Texas, Georgia, and Vermont—are blending the data in the same way. Until last week, Virginia likewise mixed viral and antibody test results, but it reversed course. Maine similarly separated its data on Wednesday; Vermont authorities claimed they didn't even know they were doing this. After the Richmond Times-Dispatch and The Atlantic covered, the governor apologized for the practice.
Many epidemiologists say data from antibody tests and active virus tests should never be mixed. Why? It's because diagnostic testing seeks to quantify the amount of active disease in the population. Also, patients who have had both diagnostic and serology tests could be counted twice.
A report in the New York Times said epidemiologists, state health officials, and a spokeswoman for the C.D.C. said there was no ill intent. They claim they were exhausted and overworked.
School To Prison Pipeline
To add insult to injury and sow more confusion, the C.D.C. just released school guidelines in the fall. The never-ending list of rules makes it seem like kids will be entering a maximum-security prison instead of school.
They have a laundry list of guidelines schools might want to implement, but they have a disclaimer:
Schools can determine, in collaboration with state and local health officials to the extent possible, whether and how to implement these considerations while adjusting to meet the unique needs and circumstances of the local community. Implementation should be guided by what is feasible, practical, acceptable, and tailored to the needs of each community.
"What is feasible, practical, and acceptable." Great. Tell me what is feasible, practical, and acceptable about any of these:
Broadcast regular announcements on reducing the spread of COVID-19 on P.A. systems.
Include messages (for example, videos) about behaviors that prevent the spread of COVID-19 when communicating with staff and families (such as on school websites, in emails, and on school social media accounts).
Discourage sharing of items that are difficult to clean or disinfect.
Keep each child's belongings separated from others' and in individually labeled containers, cubbies, or areas.
Ensure adequate supplies to minimize sharing of high-touch materials to the extent possible (e.g., assigning each student their art supplies, equipment) or limit use of supplies and equipment by one group of children at a time and clean and disinfect between use.
Avoid sharing electronic devices, toys, books, and other games or learning aids.
Space seating/desks at least 6 feet apart when feasible.
Turn desks to face in the same direction (rather than facing each other), or have students sit on only one side of tables, spaced apart.
When possible, create distance between children on school buses (e.g., seat children one child per row, skip rows).
Install physical barriers, such as sneeze guards and partitions, particularly in areas where it is difficult for individuals to remain at least 6 feet apart (e.g., reception desks).
Provide physical guides, such as tape on floors or sidewalks and signs on walls, to ensure that staff and children remain at least 6 feet apart in lines and at other times (e.g., guides for creating "one-way routes" in hallways).
Close communal use shared spaces such as dining halls and playgrounds with shared playground equipment if possible; otherwise, stagger use and clean and disinfect between use.
Add physical barriers, such as flexible plastic screens, between bathroom sinks, especially when they cannot be at least 6 feet apart.
Have children bring their meals as feasible or serve individually plated meals in classrooms instead of in a communal dining hall or cafeteria while ensuring the safety of children with food allergies.pdf icon.
Use disposable food service items (e.g., utensils, dishes). If disposable items are not feasible or desirable, ensure that all non-disposable food service items are handled with gloves and washed with dish soap and hot water or in a dishwasher. After removing their gloves, individuals should wash their hands after directly handling used food service items.
If food is offered at any event, have pre-packaged boxes or bags for each attendee instead of a buffet or family-style meal. Avoid sharing food and utensils and ensure the safety of children with food allergies.pdf icon.
What a horrible way to live. I hope NO school system does any of this.
Many of the other guidelines are reasonable. The problem I have with most of these guidelines is this; why are these things recommended now, and not every year when there is a deadly flu season? More kids die from the flu every year than from COVID-19.
Thank you for reading Think Things Through. I encourage you to forward this newsletter to your friends in hopes that they too, will like the content. As of now, this newsletter is free. In a few months, most of the newsletters will be available to paying subscribers only. Thanks for reading.
You can sign up for a membership here:
Interesting articles you might want to read:
New York coronavirus fatalities fall to the lowest level since March Coronavirus deaths in New York state have fallen below 100, Gov. Andrew Cuomo said on Saturday, marking the lowest daily death toll from the virus since March 24.
NBA in talks to resume play at Disney's ESPN Wide World of Sports Complex The NBA has entered into exploratory conversations with the Walt Disney Company about restarting the remainder of its season at Disney's ESPN Wide World of Sports Complex in Orlando, Florida, in late July, NBA spokesperson Mike Bass said Saturday.
‘Tens of thousands of coronavirus tests have been double-counted, officials admit‘ – Diagnostic kits which involve nasal and saliva samples of a single individual are being counted as two tests, says the Telegraph
Your Next "Stimulus Check" Could Have Big Strings Attached Forget about free money -- you might have to do more to earn any future aid from the federal government.
‘Every part of England would pass Germany’s Covid test‘ – Ross Clark in the Spectator suggests forgetting the R number and using the same metric used in Germany and Ontario – if the no. of infections falls below 50/100,00 then continue easing restrictions
‘Stanford Professor and Nobel Prize Winner Explains this Viral Lockdown – Fully!‘ – Ivor Cummins, aka the Fat Emperor, talks to Professor Michael Levitt about the lockdown policy
‘Feel a Little Shame for the Lost Soul of the Nation‘ – Avay Shukla makes a powerful moral case for ending the lockdown in India.
‘The worst week for Britain’s economy laid bare – in five charts‘ – The Telegraph publishes five charts to show the economic devastation unleashed by the lockdown. Sobering
‘Lockdowns Haven’t Proved They’re Worth the Havoc‘ – Joe Nocera in Bloomberg contrasts the reaction to COVID-19 with the reaction to the Hong Kong Flu pandemic in 1968-69
‘We Can’t Go On Living in a Two-Meter World‘ – More skepticism from Bloomberg
‘Two in three of us have put on weight in lockdown‘ – I am among the 66.6%
‘Next week’s clap for carers should be the last‘ – The inventor of ‘clap for carers’ calls time on the virtue-signaling seals
‘California doctors say they’ve seen more deaths from suicide than coronavirus since lockdowns‘ – Disturbing report in the Washington Examiner
‘Justice Dept. supports downstate lawmaker’s lawsuit against Illinois stay-at-home order‘ – The US Justice Department is helping a state congressman in Chicago sue, Governor JB Pritzker, over stay-at-home order
‘Tokyo Gov. Yuriko Koike reveals restart plan as end of emergency looms‘ – Governor of Tokyo gives short shrift to the idea of a “new normal”. He told a meeting of the city’s coronavirus taskforce yesterday: “We need to proceed cautiously, but each day the city meets these criteria is another step toward reclaiming the lives we had before.”
Clayton Craddock is a father, independent thinker, and the founder and publisher of the social and political commentary newsletter Think Things Through and host of the Think Things Through Podcast.
Twitter: @claytoncraddock